I currently play super old SM4's and have been ready to buy new ones for some time now.
I have tried the wedge selector tool on Vokey.com probably hundreds of times and have checked countless pros WITBs to get an ideal setup for pros with similar swings/thoughts.
I purchased a 54-11M and a 60-07S when they were released and did not really know anything about what I got, I just purchased them off based off of the bounce I thought would work for me.
I would prefer your input on here rather than a fitter that does it indoors on mats or on a sandy/chewed up driving range that would be nearby. I also do not want to go to an expensive fitter at a resort as I feel like I can figure it out here.
I live in South Florida and some courses can have soft turf in the fairway, firm turf around the greens, or firm fairways and soft turf around the greens. Same applies to traps - beachy traps with no bottom or hardpan clay-like lie. And can change all within the same course. I play public courses and not always perfectly manicured ones haha
I play a 48* blade pitching wedge and am debating going: 52-12F, 56-10S, and 60-08M.
I also was thinking of going with a 56-14F - my only fear is that I will have too much bounce for when I play a firmer course and kind of want to use the 56/60 interchangeably for the grind/bounce.
My yardages with current setup is PW - 140, 54* - 115, 60* - 90
The question that bothers me is "do you take shallow or deep divots" - that depends on the course conditions. If it is firm, they will be shallow and if it is soft, they will be deep.
A shot that is difficult for me would be a short, into-the-grain lie or an extremely thin grass / 'sandy/dusty/dry' type lie around the green. It always feels like the club digs immediately regardless of what bounce I use. I have no problem with firm turf or plush lies as I feel like I can always nip it fine. I always preferred using my 60* but now started trying my 54 to get out of the squirrelly lies and think that going from a 54 to a 52 and 56 would help better with versatility/grinds when the lies are awkward for me.
Thank you for reading this ridiculously long post and helping me decide what to do!